See it or Skip it: The Women

September 12, 2008 at 7:38am PST
Photos: Picturehouse Entertainment

After years of largely abandoning the “Chick Flick,” this summer Hollywood took a page from the Spice Girls and tried to imbue their offerings with Girl Power. Their sad, misguided efforts produced some of the most cloying, least-realistic portrayals of women ever seen on screen.

Meryl Streep was made to prance around Greece like an adolescent idiot in Mamma Mia!, the Sex and the City movie was so whiney and ill-conceived, it decimated the memory of a beloved series and now The Women arrives, tired, dated and contrived. It’s hard to believe it’s based on a biting, witty film classic.

Meg Ryan, botoxed and collagened to within an inch of her life, stars as a woman dealing with the fall out of her husband’s affair assisted by her gaggle of girlfriends: horrendously over the top Debra Messing; Annette Benning, who does her mighty best to raise the material she’s saddled with; and Jada Pinkett-Smith, who apparently believes being a lesbian means sitting with your legs spread and an arm over the back of a chair. The foursome is entirely unbelievable as a group of friends, lacking any chemistry or connection, but we’re still tortured by their loathsome, forced, shrill, “look at how much fun we’re supposed to be having” antics.

Writer-director Diane English, once so brilliant and savvy as the mind behind Murphy Brown, keeps the film’s original plot intact, borrows dialogue heavily and maintains the conceit of not having even one man on screen…but, 75 years later, none of it makes sense. This “updated” version is a clunky, retro mess that defiles its roots and is chockful of characters who are unredeemable. That ain't Girl Power.

Skip it.

Comments

figured as much

Ms English used to be great. Now she's just crazy

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <br> <br /> <p> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <b> <i> <u> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

F. Gary Gray's latest effort, Law Abiding Citizen, starring Jamie Foxx and Gerard Butler, is a knockout! Exhilirating, wry and breathcatchingly paced, it's a stellar accomplishment for everyone involved. Hell yeah you should see it!

Read More
Scott Hicks, the director of Shine, and Clive Owen teamed up for this gloriously beautiful if underwhelming project. It's not that it's bad, it's just not that memorable and with such supreme talent attached, I was hoping for and expecting a lot more.

Read More
Oh, Diablo Cody, why'd you have to do it? I love you so long...and then you made this. Megan Fox does what she always does, she looks hot. At least there's that. Sophmoric, unfunny and obsessively idiosyncratic, it's a painful movie going experience.



Read More
Chocolate and peanut butter. Spaghetti and meatballs. Bobcat Goldthwait and profanity. Two great tastes that taste great together. Gone is the Bobcat of the Police Academy movies and in his stead is a fantastic writer-director who's able to orchestrate the most brilliantly, hilarious vulgarity imaginable. World's Greatest Dad is a fantastic dark comedy (very dark) that features Robin Williams' best performance since Good Will Hunting. See it!

Read More